Personlly i think the only person that is not such a murderer is dr.armstrong and Tony because tony didn’t really mean too and Dr. armstrong just maid a mistake PAUL ANDERSON

Comment by    Paul Anderson 11.28.07 @ 1:22 pm

this book is really good.
i love it.
It is AWESOME!
i cant believe that was the killer! it was so unexpected!
gahh. i had my suspicions throughout the book but not that pesron.

i sooo recommend this book!♥

Comment by    Alexia 11.28.07 @ 1:41 pm

Oh My Gosh I thought the book was so good, and i thought some murders were more faultful, and I just realy enjoyed it

Tori McMlure!!♥

Comment by    Tori McClure 11.28.07 @ 1:41 pm

I personally think that none of them were killers. I just think that each of them were coincedentally in the WRONG place at the WRONG time. I do believe, however, that each of the ten people think that they are murderers as well as U.N.Owen. They just haven’t considered maybe, that all of their “murders” were just coincidences. But, that’s just what I think!

What do all of y’all think???

Comment by    colin R. 11.28.07 @ 1:54 pm

well i think that all of the people were killers because in most of the crimes was like they murder them. i mean if they wouldnt have done anything wrong the people that they “killed” wouldnt of died in the first place and none of them would be dead right now. and that was a reason why they all got on the island anyways is because they killed people that the judge and people wouldnt have charged them for or anything.

so yeah i think that they were all murders.

Comment by    Shainna. 12.03.07 @ 10:11 am

well i dont thank all of the people on that island, where murders. some of them were just freak accidents.but i deffinatly recommend reading this book, it’s boring at the begining, then once you start reading you really get into it.

-hannah nichole♥

Comment by    hannah nichole (: 12.03.07 @ 10:19 am

well i think some of them were murderers because even some of them addmitted to it but some like anthony marston (Tony) didnt mean to kill the kids he was just going so fast and didnt have time to slow down! and Dr. Armsrong was drunk even though it was his responsibility he still didnt mean to kill a woman like perposly!! these are just my oppinion but i do wish the book would have had the ppl killed faster!! but it was still a pretty good book!!

Comment by    Hope Bailey 12.03.07 @ 12:00 pm

I think they all are suspicius in there own way.
Like Vera Claythorne had that mischeivious look on her face always.. To learn more about the other 9 characters read The Book. ITS SOMETHIG YOU DONT WANNA MISS.
thanksss.

Comment by    Rylei C 12.03.07 @ 12:01 pm

Well my opinion is that all of them are murderes because even if their crimes are on purpose or on accident they killed somebody and that to me is a murder.

Comment by    Elizabeth 12.03.07 @ 12:05 pm

omg!!! i loved the book and the movie! the book was so unexpected! i thought that vera claythorne would have been the killer, not dr. armstrong and the judge. well anyways good book!!!
hannah gilbert!

Comment by    hannah 12.03.07 @ 12:05 pm

I thought nobody was the kilers I never thought that the judge was it that was a surpise. And it was so good that I want to buy the book and read it all over again!!

Comment by    katelyn 12.03.07 @ 12:36 pm

And Then There Were None was a wonderful novel to read. We did not expect that person to be the killer. It kept us all on the edge of our seats the whole time, the movie was very good too. We recommend you to read this book when you get the chance. We give this book two thumbs up!!

Comment by    Elizabeth & Hailee & Heatherly 12.03.07 @ 12:57 pm

i think that evet single person on the island is a murders especially Vera Claythorne because she let a child drown so her lover could get all the money and then what made me laugh was that Hugo left her and that she didnt know that he liked the kid.plus i Know Justice Wargrave was guilty cause he killed every1 including himself but what makes me wonder did any1 make him write the message in a bottle cause since they did look everywhere they never did recheck the place so i wonder if the “killer” would have placed a boat or something in one of the places that they already looked!!
Write What You Think!!!:p

Comment by    Angelyn 12.03.07 @ 5:48 pm

this book was strange i think the lest one that was the killer was emily brent because just cause she told that girl things dosen’t mean that girl as to go and kill herself and i never expected the juge to be the killer

Comment by    kindra 12.05.07 @ 10:25 am

okay first of all i didnt evan think that the judje was the killer b/c he looked very inicent ..and vera claythorn i mean who would let a young inicent kid drown that is soo CRAZY ..and that the fact that hugo left her was so funny because that is what she gets for drownin that little kid.but yeah if u wanna no more about the other ppl and what they did i think u should read the book it is so awesome .

ILY Miranda Kay♥

Comment by    miranda 12.05.07 @ 10:31 am

I just read the book called “The Notebook”.
It’s totally awesome except it isn’t exactly like the movie, but its semi – like it.
It’s about this woman named “allie” and this man named “noah” they spend all summer together and fall in love with each other, then she moves away to go to college and he stays there and they dont see each other anymore, then he goes to find her and she’s fallen in love again, gets engaged, and when trying on her wedding dress she reads an add about the house, her and noah picked out, then she goes back to seeh im and ends up breaking the promise she gave to her fiancee but you’ll have to read it yourself to find out the ending.
so go read it mayne(:
- hannah nichole eller

Comment by    Hannah Nichole Eller(: 12.05.07 @ 10:36 am

YES! i personaly think that they are all murders! because they all killed somebody to get something that wanted! and if they did not fisically kill them then they kept something from them that made them die that had to have to keep them from dying!

Comment by    haley 12.06.07 @ 10:11 am

I think they are all killers. They have all got a cold heart. Shame on them.
Brittany M.

Comment by    brittanym. 12.06.07 @ 8:05 pm

Well both the movie and the book were surprising because you would never think that the judge would be the murderer both are different but interesting.

Comment by    Elizabeth 12.19.07 @ 9:10 am